Group members: Eric Tu, Siddarth Sen, Keng Jae Bang, Dea Ho Moon
Questions on Gender Issues:
How would you describe the power dynamics in this scenario? Who has power? Is power abused? How?
Only men have power in this movie. Such men are: Henry, the senator, the head engineer at the DOT, and Julie’s boss. To make important decisions, only men collaborate with each other, with little regard for the opinions of females.
These men are not only more powerful in terms of engineering and the work they produce (as evidenced by Julie’s work being plagiarized and taken by her boss as his thesis), but also socially. Women are banned from the male exclusive events such as fishing where the discussing of major decision occurs. While men have a social life outside of work, the women can’t face their problems and comfort themselves with food. Women are the ones with problems of being ignored, and yet the movie presents them as being unable to face the problems put upon them by men. This means that the male-dominated power dynamic will continue to be preserved.
What are some of the problems with the way gender issues were portrayed in the movie?
The movie perpetuated stereotypes with women talking and doing trivial things such as complaining while on a treadmill and eating cake, but they also demonstrated the stereotype that female engineers are incompetent. In the movie, the female engineers only talk about work outside, complain, and even with the work they do, they don’t perform it well or up to a standard acceptable by men.
Besides Laura and Julie, we see that Julie’s boss also treats his wife in a completely trivial way, as an object. When the boss’s wife is out of town, he doesn’t abide by the relationship that he is in, and only wants to go out with Julie. During this encounter, we witness that the sexual harassment is more about the sexuality of a female rather than the power and sex discrimination endemic to being a female engineer. Along with this theme, we see that Laura is not hit on because she is not seen as attractive.
The title of the film is also portrayed in a way that women only relate to men by relationship and have no definition outside of being related to men. In the film, we see that Laura and Julie only get their positions, and are only treated well in the positions, because they are related to their father.